Indoor S’Mores for a Group

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

As summer comes to a close this evening, I would like to pay homage to a favorite taste of summer*: The S’More.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock* Also fall, and winter. And I have never turned down a Spring S’More.

My cousin SFH put the idea for Indoor S’Mores for a Group in my head before her annual July 4 party this year, and it has been looming large since then. She explained that she wanted to make S’Mores for her guests and asked if she could make my Microwave S’Mores for a sizable group, in advance. Apartment living has so many perks, but darned if a fire pit wouldn’t come in handy for times like these! I told her I didn’t think the microwave would work out, but the oven would be a good alternative. I quickly successfully made one lonely S’More in the oven, and sent her a few links to blogs that seemed to have decent explanations for that method, and she reported back good results.

But I wanted to do it, and make a test batch (or 4), and post about it. My job SO gets in the way of critical research and development like this.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil CrockMaking a large tray of S’mores is just something I wouldn’t let myself do by myself. One of the first questions people ask me when they learn I like to bake and cook is “How do you not eat it all?!” Well, some things I would. Like this:

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

I would own that tray of S’mores. And, actually, I did. Did you know that S’mores will keep in an airtight container on your counter until you eat them all for at least 5 days? Now you know. {Um, no reason. Totally unrelated to that actual tray of S’Mores, I swear…}

So in August at LS’s Bachelorette weekend, I told the group that I wanted to do a post on making a large quantity of S’Mores inside, and they were my guinea pigs.  There were no objections; there was some confusion about why I would think that there were people who might opt out; and funny enough, there was a good deal of stimulating discussion about many aspects of S’Mores – I loved it! {And I also loved my photo shoot with the bachelorette herself!}

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

Photo courtesy of KB, taken with LS’s iPhone

So, I got to work. Did you know that one box of graham crackers and 4 hershey bars will yield you exactly 24 S’Mores? I tell you, serious R&D here.

Part of the S’Mores discourse revolved around Hershey’s chocolate. Now, I am the type of chocoholic that might prefer one chocolate to another, but would never turn down chocolate. But as my friends develop more refined palates – palates that have lived in foreign countries and/or gravitate toward dark chocolate – some have become skeptical of a good ol’ Hershey Bar. But they were all troopers – selfless, even – and tried a S’More for the team.Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

Without fail, every person who had had doubts about Hershey chocolate said that maybe that’s what had been missing from their S’Mores attempts. A taste of nostalgia, or maybe actual chocolate science. Maybe we will never know. There was another eddy carrying the notion that S’Mores in general were too sweet and the chocolate didn’t melt right. That it was weird when the marshmallows were melted but the chocolate was solid and kind of cold. We rectified these prejudices by using just 2 squares (“pips”) of Hershey’s; the few minutes in the oven under the heating element warmed the chocolate through as well.


Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

Without further ado, to assembling we go.

Break the rectangle graham cracker boards into squares, and lay 12 squares on a rimmed baking sheet. Top each with 2 pips of Hershey’s chocolate.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

Pop the marshmallows on, flat sides up and down so they don’t roll away.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

With the briefest of blasts under the broiler, or at 450 degrees if you are not a broiler type, and you get this:

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

REALLY brief. Like, stare at them – do not walk away!

Top them off with additional squares, and VOILA.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil Crock

Let me know if you want prints of this one. It can be arranged.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group by My Utensil CrockI was not kidding when I said that S’mores will last in airtight containers on your kitchen counter. Well, by that I mean, they won’t go bad. Whether they last kind of depends whether you are home staring at them or not. While nothing beats a fresh and hot S’More, I was surprised to learn that the marshmallows stayed soft and chewy for several days after the S’Mores are made. The melted chocolate solidifies where it melted around the marshmallow, but also stays pliable. So in a pinch, don’t be shy to make a batch a day in advance if you have an offsite S’Mores necessity and they need to be transported.

Indoor S'Mores for a Group
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Who doesn't love a S'More?! Make a whole tray of this nostalgic treat in 5 minutes or less in your kitchen. Great for company, vacations, and staycations.
Recipe type: Snacks, Dessert
Serves: 24 S'Mores
  • 1 box graham crackers, each rectangle broken into squares
  • 4 Hershey's bars (the regular, small, non-king-sized kind)
  • 24 marshmallows
  1. Set the top rack in the oven 2-3" below the heating element. If you have a gas oven, move the rack down to 3-4" away.
  2. On a large rimmed pan, set out 12 squares of graham crackers.
  3. Top each with 2 squares (pips) of Hershey's.
  4. Top each with one marshmallow, flat sides up and down so they don't roll away.
  5. Carefully move the tray to the oven.
  6. Pull up a chair and watch the magic happen. It may be even faster in a gas oven, but it should only take about 1 to 2 minutes for the marshmallows to brown.
  7. Remove when the marshmallows are cooked to your liking. {Again, be very careful if you are using gas!}
  8. Once the tray is removed, top the S'Mores immediately with additional graham cracker squares and move to a plate to cool.
  9. Repeat with the remaining ingredients for a second batch.

Thanks so much to my guinea pigs! You are truly selfless 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Rate this recipe: